The challenger. Trails the leader on the balanced score. Its widest win over the field is analyst sentiment.
The verdict
CINF leads clearly (63/100 vs PUK 47) under a balanced style, mostly on risk (calm = better). But PUK wins on analyst sentiment, so the comparison turns on what you weight. Switch your goal above and watch the scores move.
THE SCORECARD · FACTOR BY FACTOR · the best value in each row is ticked, and a tie ticks every tied column · weight bar shows how much it counts for your goal
P/E bases differ: trailing for CINF, fiscal 2025 for PUK.
Growth
Revenue & earnings momentum
1×
✓ —
66
—
3
Profitability & quality
Margins & return on capital
1×
Net 20%
TTM through Sep 30, 2026
49
✓ Net 36% · ROIC 47%
fiscal 2025
66
Total return
Share-price change with dividends reinvested
1×
✓ 5Y +12%/yr
65
5Y −7%/yr
11
Risk (calm = better)
Volatility & drawdown
1×
✓ β 0.4 · DD −36%
85
β 1.0 · DD −62%
18
Balance sheet†
Debt vs cash cushion
1×
—
91
✓ —
92
Dividend & income
Cash paid to you
1×
✓ 1.93% yield· A
45
1.30% yield· D
33
Analyst sentiment
Forward EPS growth (consensus)
1×
Est EPS −1%/yr · 6 analysts
48
✓ Est EPS +21%/yr · 3 analysts
82
† Balance sheet is scored on 5 peer percentiles (current ratio, quick ratio, net debt/EBITDA, interest coverage and debt/equity). The cell shows one of them, so a column can lead on the printed number and still lose the row.
The letter beside the dividend yield is our dividend-safety grade (A+ to F), a read on how likely that dividend is to be cut. It does not grade the yield.
GrowthCurrently 3/100 (—). Taking it to 100 would lift the balanced score by 12 points, the biggest single move available.
Total returnCurrently 11/100 (5Y −7%/yr). Taking it to 100 would lift the balanced score by 11 points, the next biggest.
Scores are Tenet composites, 0–100, reweighted for your selected goal. Seven of the eight factors are sector percentiles; analyst sentiment is an absolute curve on forward EPS growth, capped at 100, so two very high-growth names can share the top score. Moat/durability is not scored (qualitative, not measurable). Comparison is decision-support, not a recommendation · past performance does not predict future returns · Not investment advice · prices are each company's own latest close, the newest here being Nov 16, 2026 · valuation, growth, quality and balance scores from the Nov 16, 2026 scoring run · analyst consensus, return, risk and income scores computed Nov 16, 2026.