⌕

Franco-Nevada (FNV) vs Vale (VALE)

Your goal
● Balanced style: every factor counts equally.
#1 FIT · LEADS
66
Franco-Nevada Corporation
$247.01 · $48B
Strongest balance sheetFastest growerCalmest ride
of the stocks compared here

The front-runner. Leads the balanced score. Its widest win over the field is balance sheet.

#2 FIT
52
Vale S.A.
$11.22 · $48B
Cheapest
of the stocks compared here

The challenger. Trails the leader on the balanced score. Its widest win over the field is valuation.

FNV leads clearly (66/100 vs VALE 52) under a balanced style, mostly on balance sheet. But VALE wins on valuation, so the comparison turns on what you weight. Switch your goal above and watch the scores move.

THE SCORECARD · FACTOR BY FACTOR · the best value in each row is ticked, and a tie ticks every tied column · weight bar shows how much it counts for your goal

FactorFNVVALE
Overall fit score
weighted for your balanced goal
✓ 66
52
7 of 8 factors known
Valuation
Cheaper for what you get
1×
P/E 43 · EV/EBITDA 29.0
P/E latest fiscal year
16
✓ P/E 20 · EV/EBITDA 9.5
P/E latest fiscal year
72
Growth
Revenue & earnings momentum
1×
✓ —
77
—
34
Profitability & quality
Margins & return on capital
1×
✓ Net 61% · ROIC 13%
76
Net 5% · ROIC 5%
63
Total return
Share-price change with dividends reinvested
1×
✓ 5Y +12%/yr
63
5Y +6%/yr
50
Risk (calm = better)
Volatility & drawdown
1×
✓ β 0.4 · DD −37%
93
β 0.7 · DD −50%
76
Balance sheet†
Debt vs cash cushion
1×
✓ Current ratio 8.30
92
Current ratio 1.15
14
Dividend & income
Cash paid to you
1×
✓ 0.69% yield· B
43
—
—
Analyst sentiment
Forward EPS growth (consensus)
1×
✓ Est EPS +10%/yr · 5 analysts
65
Est EPS +2%/yr · 8 analysts
52
† Balance sheet is scored on 5 peer percentiles (current ratio, quick ratio, net debt/EBITDA, interest coverage and debt/equity). The cell shows one of them, so a column can lead on the printed number and still lose the row.
The letter beside the dividend yield is our dividend-safety grade (A+ to F), a read on how likely that dividend is to be cut. It does not grade the yield.
Loading chart…
WHERE EACH ONE IS STRONG
GrowthValueQualityReturnSafety
Income axis omitted: no data for one of these stocks.
■ FNV■ VALE
CAN YOU STOMACH THE RIDE?
Worst drawdownBeta (vs market)VolatilityHistory
FNV−37%0.4132%5Y
VALE−50%0.7035%5Y
THE CASE FOR & AGAINST EACH
BULL CASE

▲ Leads on balance sheet (score 92). Current ratio 8.30 is one of the 5 inputs.

▲ Leads on growth: — (score 77).

BEAR CASE

▼ Weakest on valuation: P/E 43 · EV/EBITDA 29.0 (score 16).

BULL CASE

▲ Leads on valuation: P/E 20 · EV/EBITDA 9.5 (score 72).

BEAR CASE

▼ Weakest on balance sheet (score 14). Current ratio 1.15 is one of the 5 inputs.

▼ Weakest on growth: — (score 34).

WHAT COULD CHANGE THE SCORE
ValuationCurrently 16/100 (P/E 43 · EV/EBITDA 29.0). Taking it to 100 would lift the balanced score by 10 points, the biggest single move available.
Dividend & incomeCurrently 43/100 (0.69% yield). Taking it to 100 would lift the balanced score by 7 points, the next biggest.
Balance sheetCurrently 14/100 (Current ratio 1.15). Taking it to 100 would lift the balanced score by 12 points, the biggest single move available.
GrowthCurrently 34/100 (—). Taking it to 100 would lift the balanced score by 9 points, the next biggest.
Scores are Tenet composites, 0–100, reweighted for your selected goal. Seven of the eight factors are sector percentiles; analyst sentiment is an absolute curve on forward EPS growth, capped at 100, so two very high-growth names can share the top score. Moat/durability is not scored (qualitative, not measurable). Comparison is decision-support, not a recommendation · past performance does not predict future returns · Not investment advice · prices are each company's own latest close, the newest here being Nov 13, 2026 · valuation, growth, quality and balance scores from the Nov 16, 2026 scoring run · analyst consensus, return, risk and income scores computed Nov 16, 2026.

Install Tenet on your phone

Tenet home pageMethodology© 2026 Tenet Investing Inc.

Data from Intrinio and Financial Modeling Prep.