Piotroski F-Score: The Nine Tests on a Real Company
A score from 0 to 9, built from nine pass-or-fail tests on a company’s last two annual reports. What each test checks, how to read the total, where it misleads, and one company’s score read from its Tenet report.
What the Piotroski F-score measures
The Piotroski F-score is a nine-point checklist of financial strength, published by the accounting professor Joseph Piotroski in 2000. It uses nothing but a company’s financial statements: no share price, no forecast and no analyst opinion. Each test the company passes earns one point, so the score runs from 0, the weakest, to 9, the strongest.
Most of the tests compare the latest fiscal year with the one before. The score therefore asks two questions at once: is the business profitable and soundly funded now, and is it moving in the right direction? A large company with a comfortable balance sheet that slipped on most measures last year can score lower than a smaller company that is still weaker but improving. That is the point of the design: the score reads the direction of the numbers as much as their level.
Piotroski built the checklist for a specific problem. Companies that look cheap on price to book are often cheap because the business is in trouble, and a low multiple alone cannot tell the recovering company from the failing one. The checklist was his way of sorting that group using public accounting data alone, with tests simple enough that anyone holding the annual report can repeat them.
Because it reads only the annual statements, the score changes once a year for most companies, when the new annual report is filed. It is a slow measure by design, closer to an annual health check than to a signal that moves with the news.
The nine Piotroski F-score tests, in three groups
Every test is pass or fail, worth one point or none; there are no half points. The tests are grouped the way the original paper groups them.
Profitability: four tests
- Return on assets is positive. Net income divided by total assets is above zero, so the company made a profit on what it owns. The return on assets guide explains the ratio itself.
- Operating cash flow is positive. The business took in more cash from its operations than it paid out to run them, before any spending on new equipment.
- Return on assets improved. The ratio is higher than it was the year before.
- Operating cash flow is larger than net income. Reported profit is backed by cash rather than by accounting accruals such as rising receivables. This is the quality test: profit that does not turn into cash deserves a closer look, a theme the free cash flow guide follows further.
Leverage, liquidity and funding: three tests
- Long-term debt fell relative to assets. Long-term debt as a share of total assets is lower than a year earlier.
- The current ratio improved. Current assets cover current liabilities by a wider margin than a year earlier. The current ratio guide covers what a good level looks like.
- No new shares were issued. The company did not raise money by selling stock, which would spread the business over more shares. The test reads a company that needed outside equity as a weaker one.
Operating efficiency: two tests
- Gross margin improved. Revenue minus the direct cost of sales, as a share of revenue, is higher than a year earlier, a sign of pricing power or cheaper inputs. The gross margin guide explains the line.
- Asset turnover improved. Revenue divided by total assets is higher than a year earlier, so the company is producing more sales from what it owns.
Five of the nine tests are about change, so a company needs two consecutive annual reports to be scored at all. The methodology page lists the places where Tenet’s version of the tests departs from the original paper.
How to read a Piotroski F-score
There are no official bands, but readers usually group the score in three ranges.
Profitable, funded more conservatively than a year earlier, and improving on most measures.
Some tests pass and some fail. The individual tests show which way the business is moving.
Most measures deteriorated. A low price on a company like this often reflects real trouble.
Many value investors treat a score of 7 or higher as the mark of a healthy company that is improving. Tenet’s own Piotroski playbook sets its bar at 8 or higher. Value investors often combine a cheap valuation (say, a low price to book) with a high F-score to avoid buying companies that are cheap for a reason.
Read the tests, not only the total. Two companies can both score 6 for opposite reasons: one passes every profitability test and fails on debt and new shares, the other is soundly funded but losing margin. The total hides which story is which, and the tests tell it.
Read the movement as well as the level. A company that climbed from 4 to 7 over two years is telling a different story from one that slid from 8 to 5, even though the second still has the higher score. Because most tests compare two years, a run of scores is more informative than any single one.
Compare like with like. A utility and a software company have very different needs for capital, debt and new equipment, so a 6 in one industry is not the same reading as a 6 in another. Comparing a company with its own record and with its closest peers keeps the score honest.
To see the nine tests on real companies, open Microsoft’s Piotroski tests and Apple’s Piotroski tests on the Tenets tab of each company’s Tenet report, where every test is listed with its result and the years it compares.
Where the Piotroski F-score misleads
Banks, insurers and property trusts. The checklist was designed for industrial companies. A bank reports no gross margin, a current ratio means little on its balance sheet, and borrowing is part of how it does business, so several tests either cannot be passed or say little about strength. A financial company’s score is best read with that in mind.
One unusual year. Most tests compare two years, so a single odd year swings the score: an asset sale that lifts return on assets, a write-down that cuts it, or a large acquisition that adds assets, debt and new shares at once. The score moves even though the underlying business may not have changed much.
Companies investing for growth. A young company that is losing money on purpose while it builds, or that sells shares to fund expansion, fails several tests by construction. The score describes its current finances accurately, but it was not built to judge that kind of business.
The share test is strict. In its original form, any increase in the share count fails it, so a company that pays its staff partly in stock can lose the point for routine reasons. Some versions allow a small tolerance; the methodology page gives Tenet’s.
It lags. Annual statements arrive weeks after the year ends and describe a year that is already over. A business that turned sharply since then will not show it until the next report.
It is not a valuation and not a forecast. A high score says the accounts improved last year. It says nothing about whether the share price already reflects that, and nothing about next year. The Altman Z-score is a different check on a company’s distance from financial distress and is often read beside it.
Screening for it on Tenet
Tenet runs the F-Score as a nightly playbook: the Piotroski F-Score screen lists every US stock of $200M or more in market value scoring 8 or higher, recomputed each night with all nine tests shown for every name. The free view publishes the top 5 by Tenet Score, each with its F-Score, and the rest comes with Premium. Every stock report also shows its own current F-Score with the nine tests broken out, so you never see the number without the reasoning.
Each Ruleset is independently developed by Tenet based on investment criteria described in publicly available sources associated with the referenced investor. References to third-party names and trademarks are for identification purposes only. Tenet is not affiliated with, sponsored by, endorsed by or otherwise associated with any referenced investor or trademark owner. Any selections, analyses, backtests, scores and performance information reflect Tenet's own interpretation and implementation and have not been prepared, reviewed or approved by the referenced investor or trademark owner. Third-party names and trademarks remain the property of their respective owners. Inputs are derived from regulatory filings and normalized within Tenet's fundamentals database. Not investment advice.
To build the idea yourself in the screener, add the score to a custom screen (Ultimate). Tenet’s own playbook uses the stricter 8+ cut:
See the syntax in the formula documentation, or read how we compute the inputs in methodology notes.
Try the Piotroski F-score calculator
Toggle each test below to see how the total moves and which band it lands in. The starting position is a made-up company; the calculator reads no company’s statements.
The reading below is the other half: one real company’s score as its Tenet report prints it, with the fiscal year it covers. Its nine tests are on the same report’s Tenets tab.
On a real company
See Microsoft's Piotroski F-score on the Statistics tab.
The methodology page shows how the Piotroski F-Score screen uses the score.
Educational, not a recommendation.
Frequently asked questions
There is no official cut-off. Scores of 8 or 9 are usually read as strong and 0 to 3 as weak, and many value investors treat 7 or higher as a sign of a healthy company that is improving. The score means most when it is compared with the same company's earlier years and with companies in the same industry.
Four profitability tests: positive return on assets, positive operating cash flow, a higher return on assets than the year before, and operating cash flow above net income. Three funding tests: less long-term debt relative to assets, a higher current ratio, and no new shares issued. Two efficiency tests: a higher gross margin and a higher asset turnover.
Only partly. The tests were designed for industrial companies. Banks and insurers report no gross margin, a current ratio means little on a bank's balance sheet, and borrowing is part of how a bank does business. Several tests either cannot be passed or say little, so a financial company's score is best read with that in mind, or set aside.

