How AXS measures up against value, income, timing, and long-hold tenets. Every criterion shows the number as of the last close and the pass rule. Always free.
The tenets below and the 0-100 Tenet Score on this report are two separate computations: each tenet runs its own criteria and its own pass rule, while the score is a percentile composite reported as one of four verdict words (Strong, Solid, Mixed or Weak).
1 / 17 qualify todayas of close, Nov 16, 2026 · computed nightly from our fundamentals DB; point-in-time auditable.
QUALIFIES
1
meet every gate today
BORDERLINE
8
within one input of the gate
FAILS
5
miss at least one gate
UNKNOWN
3
insufficient data to judge
✓passes·✕fails·~borderline·—unknown
Growth receipts arrive in a coming release
Value — six classic philosophies
Buffett Qualitydurable moat
~ Borderline›
✓PassesROE ≥ 15%(TTM through Sep 30, 2026)17.5% · ≥ 15.0%
—Unknown — no dataGross margin ≥ 40%— · ≥ 40.0%
✓PassesNet margin ≥ 15%(fiscal 2025: trailing figures for Financial Services are still under review)15.9% · ≥ 15.0%
✕FailsCurrent ratio improving(fiscal 2025)We hold no record of the current ratio for both years for this company, so this signal could not be measured. It still scores 0 under this module's conservative rule (a point is never awarded without evidence), and it is not counted as one of the signals we were able to measure.no
✕FailsGross margin expanding(fiscal 2025)This company files on a financial-statement template with no gross-profit line (banks and insurers do not report one), so gross margin could not be measured for either year. It still scores 0 under this module's conservative rule (a point is never awarded without evidence), and it is not counted as one of the signals we were able to measure.no
—Unknown — no dataReturn on capital ≥ 25%— · ≥ 25.0%
Verdict Unknown for this set.
Verdict Unknown for this set. None of the 3 checks below carry data. The pass rule for Magic Formula is not published separately on the methodology page.About this screen ›Today's Magic Formula® list ›
Graham Defensivemargin of safety
~ Borderline›
✓PassesSize: market cap ≥ $2B$8.0B · ≥ $2.0B
—Unknown — no dataCurrent ratio ≥ 2— · ≥ 2.00
✕FailsPositive EPS 10yThe earnings per share on file for fiscal 2018 is zero while net income to common shareholders is positive, so that year is judged on net income.8y
✓PassesPays a dividend$1.32 · > 0
✓PassesEPS growth ≥ 3%/yr(fiscal 2021 to 2025)15.7% per year · ≥ 3.0%
✓PassesP/E ≤ 15(TTM through Sep 30, 2026)8.36 · ≤ 15.00
Income & Dividend Safetycoverage over headline yield
~ Borderline›
✓PassesPays a dividend$1.32 · > 0
✓PassesYield in a healthy band (not a yield trap)1.2% · 1.0%–8.0%
—Unknown — no dataCovered by free cash flow— · ≥ 1.20
✓PassesEarnings payout not stretched (FFO approx)16.9% · ≤ 85.0%
✓PassesBalance sheet can sustain the payout0.1× · ≤ 4.0×
✕FailsAnnual dividend raised 10+ years running (Aristocrat ≥25, King ≥50)0.00 · ≥ 10.00
✓PassesNo dividend cut in the last 5 yearsNo cut on record
✕Fails5-year dividend growth ≥ 5%/yr0.9% · ≥ 5.0%
Decided by the pass rule for Income & Dividend Safety.
The pass rule for Income & Dividend Safety is what decides that verdict, and it is not published separately on the methodology page. 1 of 8 carry no data.
Dividend Growthraises you can count on
~ Borderline›
✓PassesPays a dividend$1.32 · > 0
✕FailsAnnual dividend raised 10+ years running (Aristocrat ≥25, King ≥50)0.00 · ≥ 10.00
✓PassesNo dividend cut in the last 5 yearsNo cut on record
✕Fails5-year dividend growth ≥ 5%/yr0.9% · ≥ 5.0%
—Unknown — no dataCovered by free cash flow— · ≥ 1.20
✓PassesPayout not stretched (FFO approx)16.9% · ≤ 85.0%
Quality Compounderhigh returns, reinvested, few new shares
~ Borderline›
—Not scored: see the reason belowReturn on invested capital ≥ 15% in 4+ of the last 5 yearsOnly 0 of the last 5 fiscal years have return-on-invested-capital on record in our data; 4 are needed to score this criterion, so it is left unscored rather than counted against.—
✕FailsRevenue compounding ≥ 8%/yr over 5 years6.3% per year · ≥ 8.0%
✓PassesOff its 52-week high by 8–35% (a dip, not a collapse)9.4% · 8.0%–35.0%
✕FailsDip within its own normal pullback band0.22
✓PassesNot past where its dips have historically recovered from0.43
✓PassesA dip in an uptrend (above a rising 200-day)102.22
✕FailsHigher-low structure still intactstructure intact · no higher low
✓PassesClear of the earnings blackout (more than 5 days out)77.00 · > 5.00
Decided by the pass rule for Drawdown Context.
The pass rule for Drawdown Context is what decides that verdict, and it is not published separately on the methodology page.
Reversal Evidencedaily close onlysigns the pullback is turning
✕ Fails›
—Unknown — no dataA bullish MACD cross within 10 sessions— · ≤ 10.00
✓PassesReclaimed a rising 50-day EMA102.50
✕FailsPrinted a higher lowno
✕FailsA volume thrust on the turn (≥ 1.2× normal)1.07 · ≥ 1.20
✕FailsReversal signals fired: 3 of 4 (MACD·MA·HL·Vol)1.00 · ≥ 3.00
Decided by the pass rule for Reversal Evidence.
The pass rule for Reversal Evidence is what decides that verdict, and it is not published separately on the methodology page. 1 of 5 carry no data.
Not-a-Value-Trap Gatecheap for a good reason, not a broken one
✕ Fails›
✕FailsIn the cheap half of its own 5-year valuation range(through fiscal 2025)0.8×
✕FailsEarnings estimates not being cut−0.02
—Unknown — no dataReturns on capital not deteriorating—
Decided by the pass rule for Not-a-Value-Trap Gate.
The pass rule for Not-a-Value-Trap Gate is what decides that verdict, and it is not published separately on the methodology page. 1 of 3 carry no data.
Quality Floorpasses the quality/value gate on this dip
— Insufficient inputs (2 of 5 known)›
—Unknown — no dataOperating profit is positive— · > 0
—Unknown — no dataReturn on invested capital ≥ 10%— · ≥ 10.0%
—Not scored: see the reason belowA solvent balance sheet (Altman Z ≥ 1.8, net debt/EBITDA ≤ 4)The Altman Z-score isn't derivable from the statements we have on file, so this two-part test is left unscored.—
✓PassesQuality score ≥ 5063.60 · ≥ 50.00
✓PassesRevenue growing over 5 years(fiscal 2020 to 2025)6.3% per year · > 0
Verdict Unknown for this set.
Verdict Unknown for this set. 2 of 5 checks below carry data. The pass rule for Quality Floor is not published separately on the methodology page.
Qualified Dipa pullback with receipts, not a falling knife
~ Borderline›
A research signal from published criteria, not a recommendation.
✕FailsDrawdown context9.4% off its 52-week high
✕FailsReversal evidence1 of 4 signals fired
✕FailsTrap gate0 of 3 held · 1 no data
—Unknown — no dataQuality floor2 of 5 held · 3 no data
Invalidation level (structure break): below this the dip's structure has broken$94.55
✕Fails50-day average above the 200-day (uptrend stack)100.30
✓Passes50-day average sloping up0.02 · > 0
Decided by the pass rule for Trend Alignment.
The pass rule for Trend Alignment is what decides that verdict, and it is not published separately on the methodology page.
Relative Strengthoutperforming, ranked vs the universe
✕ Fails›
✓Passes3-month return in the top half of the universe0.81 · ≥ 0.50
✕Fails12-minus-1 momentum in the top half of the universe0.37 · ≥ 0.50
✓PassesRelative strength vs the S&P 500 improving0.00 · > 0
✕FailsEarnings estimates being revised up−0.02
Decided by the pass rule for Relative Strength.
The pass rule for Relative Strength is what decides that verdict, and it is not published separately on the methodology page.
Momentum Triggera trigger you can see
✕ Fails›
✓PassesMACD above its signal line2.46
—Not scored: see the reason belowBack above the 50-day on a fresh cross (≤10 sessions)This is a two-part reading (price back above the 50-day, and a bullish momentum cross inside 10 sessions) and a dated momentum cross is not on record for this name yet, so it is left unscored rather than counted either way.—
✕FailsHigher high and higher low (stair-stepping up)higher high · no higher low
✕FailsA volume thrust on the move (≥ 1.2× normal)1.07 · ≥ 1.20
Decided by the pass rule for Momentum Trigger.
The pass rule for Momentum Trigger is what decides that verdict, and it is not published separately on the methodology page. 1 of 4 carry no data.
Volatility Regimecontext, not a signal
Context, not scored›
Average daily swing: normal0.02
Volatility band width: mid-range0.67
Distance from its 52-week high: a modest pullback0.09
✓
Every verdict is auditableEach criterion shows the number as of the last close and the pass rule side by side: a receipt, not a rating. Several of these screens publish their rule in full under The screens; each row links to its own section where there is one.
!
Unknown ≠ failAn “— Unknown” verdict means the inputs were insufficient: context, not a signal, and never counted as a fail.
Common questions
How many investing rule sets does Axis Capital Holdings pass?
Axis Capital Holdings qualifies on 1 of 17 rule sets as of 2026-11-16, with 8 borderline and 5 failing.
Does Axis Capital Holdings meet the Graham Defensive criteria?
Axis Capital Holdings is borderline on the Graham Defensive rule set as of 2026-11-16.
Does Axis Capital Holdings meet the Buffett Quality criteria?
Axis Capital Holdings is borderline on the Buffett Quality rule set as of 2026-11-16.
Computed from our fundamentals DB; historical-CAGR PEG basis for Lynch. Research, not investment advice. Tenet's rulesets are independently developed from publicly available sources, and Tenet is not affiliated with, sponsored by, endorsed by or otherwise associated with any referenced investor or trademark owner. Full notice. MAGIC FORMULA is a trademark of MagicFormulaInvesting.com LLC.